COMPARATIVE REVIEW

Prehistoric, Tribal & Modern

Font De Gaume Cave-Bison Scene
 
Spanish-Mesolithic Cave
Font De Gaume Cave-Bison Scene
 
Spanish-Mesolithic Cave
In Paleolithic and Mesolithic cave art there are both similarities and differences. The example of the bison from Font de Gaume above is a good example of the stylistic characteristics of Paleolithic art.   The shaman/artist portrays the bison standing alone, using shading, naturalistic characteristics, and anatomical correctness. The shaman would have recognized that animals were the critical element for human survival so they would draw and paint them in order to  harness the animal's power through a ritual and combine it with their own. The Hunting Magic Theory developed by Henri Breuil connected the power of the animals through the shaman with the survival of primitive man. Mesolithic cave art is quite different than that of Paleolithic. The Mesolithic art is more narrative, its figures are shown in action and appear to be more abstract. The viewer can obviously see the humans are involved in a hunt.  In Paleolithic art the animals seem more powerful than man, whereas in Mesolithic man dominates the animals. 
Stonehenge-Winter Solstice setting through trilithon
Fajada Butte-Sun Dagger  showing summer solstice
Nancy Holt-Sun Tunnels showing summer solstice
Stonehenge-the Winter Solstice sun shown rising through the trilithon
Fajada Butte-Sun Dagger showing summer solstice
Nancy Holt-Sun Tunnels showing summer solstice
All throughout human history people have become dependent on seasonal notations to survive. Stonehenge, the Sun Dagger and the Sun Tunnels are all different structures, which measure the seasons and their solstices. Stonehenge, a Neolithic structure in England,  is formulated in a way where one could view the winter solstice. At the winter solstice the sun will rise directly through one of the great trilithons at the center of the circle.  This was how Neolithic man would mark the winter season and also orient the earth to the celestial heavens. The Sun Dagger at Fajada Butte has the same function but uses a simpler method. The Anasazi or Ancient Pueblo peoples constructed a spiral petroglyph on the face of the rock in such a way that allows the sun at mid-summer to shine through narrow rock openings and form a vertical line of light (the sun dagger) directly through the center of the spiral. The Sun Tunnels were the creation of a contemporary earth artist, Nancy Holt. She used massive modern pipes and at the summer and winter solstices the sun would rise and set  through the pipes.
Great Serpent Mound, Ohio
 
Robert Smithson-Spiral Jetty
Great Serpent Mound, Ohio
 
Robert Smithson-Spiral Jetty
The two artworks above have obvious similar traits in their building makeup. They are both artworks of the earth, but have different functions. The Spiral Jetty by Robert Smithson is the large earthwork from around 1970, which projected into the Great Salt Lake, and serves as a glorification to the earth, and was inspired by earthworks of the Native Americans. The Spiral Jetty, shows the symbolic representation of the spiral, and unites it with the natural elements of life and creation. It connects to the Great Serpent Mound built around c. 400 AD by Native Americans in its inspirational reference to the earth. The Serpent Mound itself has a more supernatural purpose, forming a spiraling serpent which is 11/4 miles long. Researchers believe it was a place where it's builders would gather and perform religious and environmental ceremonies.
Picasso-Head from Demoiselles
Mbuya Mask
Picasso-Demoiselles
Picasso-Head from Demoiselles
Mbuya Mask
Picasso-Demoiselles
The influences of tribal art over Pablo Picasso's Cubist works are unmistakable. In the images above,  Picasso's Les Demoiselles d'Avignon and the Mbuya (sickness) mask of Pende, the Congo, We see similar  similar stylistic traits. In the Demoiselles three of the five women have abstract, elongated and disfigured facial characteristics which, if compared to the Mbuya mask doesn't look that dissimilar. For example the figure sitting on the right looks especially comparable to the Mbuya mask. Both of their faces are broken up into two sides, they share the same elongated nose, and disproportion eyes and mouths. But why would this be? Why would such a gifted artist turn to such primitive forms of art? The answer lies with in the Mbuya mask itself. The Mbuya mask is a sickness mask used in healing ceremonies, which is why it is divided and colored in the traditional fashion of light and dark. The dark meaning sickness and the light meaning health then balances its overall composition.  Picasso was very interested in the healing qualities of African Art.