UNIT 2 INSTRUCTIONS

HOME


Deadlines

Green Zone (Mar 6-Mar 19): Essays turned in during this time period will receive comments and 10% extra credit. All discussion messages must be posted to the Discussion Forum during this time period to receive credit. If you want response to your Outline before you write the essay, you must post it to the Discussion Forum during this period. Try to do your work within this time period as much as possible to get the most out of this class.

Yellow Zone (Mar 20-23): Essays turned in during this time period will receive feedback and full credit. Nothing posted to the Discussion Forum from this point onward will receive credit or feedback. At this time, submit the collection of all Discussion Messages you wrote for this Unit to me via the Homework Submission Page. Try never to submit your essay later than this period, as doing so puts your grade in jeopardy.

Red Zone (Mar 24-27): Essays turned in during this time period will not receive any feedback, making it unlikely that you will improve your writing or raise your grade. If you didn't already do so, submit the collection of all Discussion Messages you wrote for this Unit to me via the Homework Submission Page. Try to use this time period only for true emergencies, and do NOT make a habit of turning your essays in during this period.

Since I am not monitoring your performance on the online exercises, they can be done during any "zone." Technically, the same is true of the readings and lectures, but the reality is that you'll need to have read most of these before you can successfully do the Forum messages and essay.


Textbook Readings

Unit 2 requires you to write about the articles of Chapter 9 (Chapter 13 in the 11th edition) once again, so look at the descriptions of the articles and the Essay and Discussion Forum assignments below to decide which articles you want to read. You will probably at least need to read Milgram, Asch, Zimbardo, and Fromm.

Remember that during Unit 5, you'll base your work on one of the optional novels for this course: Asimov's The Naked Sun, Benoit Duteutre’s The Little Girl and the Cigarette or Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale. You may want to begin reading the book of your choice earlier in the semester, as you will need to finish during or before the twelfth week.


Lectures

The Research Process

The following links will show you how to locate sources, either in the library or through the Internet.

How to Search an Online Library Catalog

How to Search a Database

How to Search the Web

Citing Sources and Avoiding Plagiarism

If you do not properly document your use of outside ideas, you can be charged with plagiarism, which is a crime that can ultimately get you expelled from college.  You must document your source whenever you do one of two things: 1) use a direct quote or 2) use an idea, fact, or observation that you got from an outside source EVEN IF YOU DON'T USE THE EXACT WORDS.  It's #2 that everyone forgets or ignores. The only time you don't have to document information from an outside source is if the information is such common knowledge that it could have been found in any number of sources, for example, the fact that Sacramento is the capital of California. You can read more about knowing which sources to acknowledge in this tutorial from St. Martin Press

How do you document?  There are two steps.  First, you create a Works Cited list that goes at the end of the essay.  This contains all the details about every book, article, web site, whatever, that you used.  Second, after every use of information in the essay, you put a pair of parentheses containing minimal information about where the info came from. These are called Parenthetical Citations.  More on this in a minute.

Making the Works Cited list involves very detailed and tedious steps. Luckily, free web software has become good enough that there is really no need to learn the steps yourself. I recommend www.easybib.com, which you can easily learn from their how-to video tutorial. This site will build your Works Cited list for you, and then you can paste it at the end of your essay. If you want to learn what exactly is going on, Diana Hacker’s website explains how to build the list manually. If you look through that site, you'll get an idea of how it works and be very glad you have easybib.com.

As for the parenthetical citations, the concept is actually very simple.  In the body of your essay, each time you mention information or a quote from an outside source, you put the author's last name, a space, and the page number, in a pair of parentheses.  They go outside the quote marks (if any) and before the period.  Example: Studies have shown that "most working mothers suffer from depression" (Smith 142).  If you mention the author's name already in the sentence, you don't have to duplicate it in the parenthetical citation.  What if you don't know the author's name, or the author has more than one book that you used, or the source is a website with no page numbers?  All those details can be learned with the fuller explanation available at Diana Hacker’s site

These concepts are absolutely crucial for passing English 1A.  Make sure you go to the sites listed above and read them carefully and repeatedly!

I have created a web page with an audio file that contains my own explanation and review of how to use parenthetical citations. If after reading the above sites, you're still not sure and want to try hearing the information, try my audio explanation.

Here's a youtube video that also explains mla documentation

A very brief overview (handy for quick reference) of MLA documentation is found on the last two pages of our textbook.

Here are a few last words about plagiarism in case you're still not sure.

 


Exercises

You should already have gone to Exercise Central during Unit 1 and registered with your name and email address. If not, go back to the Unit 1 instructions and perform the steps described in the Exercises section.

For Unit 2, only one exercise is assigned: #768.

There are some other exercises that will be very helpful in testing your understanding, though not part of Exercise Central. I highly recommend them, as they give helpful feedback and will ensure your mastery of the topic. They can be found here: Quiz 1, Quiz 2, Quiz 3.

 


Discussion Forum

You should already have gone to the Forum site during Unit 1 and registered with your name and email address. If not, go back to the Unit 1 instructions and perform the steps described in the Discussion Forum section.

Posting Discussion Messages (Required)

Reminder: Follow these directions very precisely. Messages that violate these directions will be deleted and will not receive any credit. 

  • Each of the questions listed below has its own thread in the Forum discussion board. Click on the question in the Forum and click the Reply button to post your message. You do not need to start new threads.
  • Before writing a post, read through ALL the other replies in the thread to make sure that you are writing something new. You don’t get credit for presenting ideas already presented. If you can't think of anything new to say, don't write on that question. Messages that just recap what someone else said get deleted.
  • It's more than okay to engage in a debate with one or more students and to post multiple replies to the same thread in which you continue the debate, ALWAYS ASSUMING that you follow basic rules of etiquette for the Internet and the College: use a respectful, professional tone free of personal insults or offensive language.

Questions for Discussion Forum 2

  1. Research and describe one psychological experiment similar to those described throughout Chapter 9 (Chapter 13 in the 11th edition) that you believe lack validity because the behavior being studied is too dissimilar to or not as complex as real-life situations. You don't need to analyze or comment on the experiment for the discussion board, just describe the experiment. but make sure it's clear what's so problematic about it in your description.

2.     Research and describe one psychological experiment similar to those described throughout Chapter 9 (Chapter 13 in the 11th edition) that you believe was unethical. You don't need to analyze or comment on the experiment for the discussion board, just describe the experiment. but make sure it's clear what's so unethical about it in your description. Make sure you choose a psychological experiment, no natural sciences.

3.     Erich Fromm's article makes an equation between being obedient and being cowardly. Describe an event from current news that shows a case where obedience can be cowardly, and be sure to both explain the events' details and to make it clear why it shows obedience as a cowardly act.

4.     The article by Lopach and Luckowski establishes a difference between civil disobedience rooted in fundamental principles and that rooted in personal preferences -- research and describe the details of one news stories that shows either acceptable or non-acceptable disobedience, and make it clear which category you would place the story in.

Posting an Outline (Optional)

You have the option to post an outline for the essay that you'll be writing so that I can give you feedback before you get too far into the writing process. Like anything else posted to the forum, it must be posted during the Green Zone. I will respond as quickly as possible, but you should expect that it may take me a couple of days. Just as importantly, I will only respond to Outlines that follow the directions below...

First, obvious as it may seem, first read through the essay choices at the bottom of this page and decide what you will write about. These aren't suggestions, they are your only options.

 

HOW TO CREATE AN OUTLINE FOR THIS CLASS

1.     The outline must begin with your thesis statement, which as explained above is exactly one sentence and states some kind of argument that is going to need supporting proof.

2.     Beneath it, list three or more major points that you will cover to prove this thesis. EVERY ENTRY IN THE OUTLINE MUST BE A COMPLETE SENTENCE. For example, if you are proving what are the causes of a certain situation, each major point will be one of the causes (e.g.,"One cause of x is y"). If you are writing to prove that something is true, each major point might be one step in your argument (e.g., "We can tell x is true because of y").

3.     Finally, beneath each major point, list at least two entries that show what kind of proof or detail you will use to explain that point. For example, if you are proving that one cause of the postal strike is bad working conditions, you would list some examples of these bad conditions. It is acceptable if you are not quite prepared with two entries for every major point when you turn in the outline, but try for as many as possible.

Sample Outline:

Thesis: Luxury cruises destroy the entire point of travel.

  1. They are devoted to covering as many destinations as possible in a short time, rather than seeing anything in depth.
    1. The Princess Mediterranean cruise covers 14 cities in 3 days.
    2. Day 3 of the cruise covers over 50 different sights spread out across Naples.
  1. They provide a predictable place to sleep and eat, sheltering people from the diversity of their destinations.
    1. You won't get to know the families that often run hotels in their own home.
    2. You won't get to feel what it's like to live in a home in these countries.
  1. They control the amount of time you can spend ashore, limiting the kinds of experiences or problems you can have.
    1. You will never learn how to solve the problem of being lost.
    2. You will never experience the nightlife.

Click here now to go to the Discussion Forum.

 


Essay

To submit the essay, visit the Homework Submission Page and log in with your name and your id#. Once you've confirmed your identity, you'll be taken to a page where you can both submit your work and see all your grades so far. Paste your essay into the field provided (don't worry about the lost formatting), and click the Submit button. To check if your essay was received, come back a second time to the Homework Submission Page and look at the "Here are your Current Grades" section. If Essay1 is listed there (even though there won't be a grade yet), then you can be sure your essay was received. If even the text Essay1 doesn't appear, there's a problem. Try again and if it still doesn't work, then let me know.

 

Remember that if you realistically expect your grades and writing to improve, you must turn your essays in before the Red Zone so that you can benefit from feedback. Waiting for the Red Zone and obtaining no feedback at all drastically decreases your probability of passing the course.

 

Above all, remember that you cannot take material from an outside source without acknowledging that you're doing so. Even if you completely reword information, you are still obligated to say, "according to Mr. Smith...." In the next unit, we'll discuss how to acknowledge your sources formally, but right from the beginning you must start the habit of always making clear when your information can from somewhere other than your own brain. Taking words or ideas without giving credit is considered plagiarism (stealing) and will result in an automatic F for the assignment and being reported to the college's disciplinary system where it will form part of your permanent record. Do whatever it takes to make it clear when your words OR ideas have come from another writer, and don't plan on saying that you "stole by accident."

 

Approved Topics for Essay 2

Choose one of the following prompts for your essay.You can use ideas from the Discussion Forum in your essay, but you cannot copy exact words unless you quote them. Cite any ideas borrowed from the forum with just the last name of the person who wrote the post, like this (Jung). Then list the forum in your Works Cited as a web page titled "English 1A Discussion Forum".

1.   Use research to find descriptions of two other psychological experiments similar to those described throughout Chapter 9 (Chapter 13 in the 11th edition) . Write an essay that discusses each of those experiments, as well as the experiment of "Opinions and Social Pressure" with the goal of arguing that their conclusions lack validity because the behavior being studied is too dissimilar or not as complex as to real-life situations. You will want to support your claims by considering real-life situations that are similar to those studied in the experiments and then showing in as much detail as possible why real-life is much more different/complex than the conditions set up in the experiment. If you see similarities among the limitations of the three studies, point them out along the way.

2.   Use research to find descriptions of two other psychological experiments similar to those described throughout Chapter 9 (Chapter 13 in the 11th edition) . Write an essay that discusses each of those experiments, as well as the experiment of "The Perils of Obedience " with the goal of arguing that the experiments are unethical. Use Baumrind's article and Parker's article (in 11th edition, Baumrind doesn’t exist but you can read it here) as a starting point, and quote or paraphrase them when discussing "The Perils of Obedience." Obviously, the criticisms of the ethics of the other two experiments should be your own. If you see similarities among the breaches in ethics of the three studies, point them out along the way. Remember: use only psychological studies - no animal testing, stem cell research or any other natural science subjects in this essay.

3.   Erich Fromm's article makes an equation between being obedient and being cowardly. Prove the truth of his equation with reference to three current events (obtained by researching new stories no more than 2 years old). In your essay, explain how each event you have researched relates to the idea that obedience can be cowardly, and draw specific comparisons to the facts of your event and the circumstances found in this chapter's readings.

4.   The article by Lopach and Luckowski (doesn’t exist in 11th edition, but you can read it here) establishes a difference between civil disobedience rooted in fundamental principles and that rooted in personal preferences -- in other words, between acceptable and unacceptable motives and means of civil disobedience. Research three news stories that relate to civil disobedience no more than 2 years old, and classify each of them as rooted in either fundamental principles or in personal preferences. That is, would Lopach and Luckowski approve? Use references to the article to make your point in each case.